Katrionna Furness won the 2018 Division 4 100-backstroke title at the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) games last Friday in Riverside. Kat is the first swimmer in Fillmore High School’s (FHS) history to win a CIF championship in the sport. She also placed 3rd in the 100 Freestyle. Pictured (right to left) at the CIF Finals are FHS Principal Tom Ito, Swim Coach Cindy Blatt, Katrionna, and Swim Coach Mike Blatt.
Katrionna Furness won the 2018 Division 4 100-backstroke title at the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) games last Friday in Riverside. Kat is the first swimmer in Fillmore High School’s (FHS) history to win a CIF championship in the sport. She also placed 3rd in the 100 Freestyle. Pictured (right to left) at the CIF Finals are FHS Principal Tom Ito, Swim Coach Cindy Blatt, Katrionna, and Swim Coach Mike Blatt.
Enlarge Photo
Fillmore’s Towne Theatre marquee reflects the community’s congratulations to Katrionna, and she will be waving to the crowd in Saturday’s May Festival Parade.
Fillmore’s Towne Theatre marquee reflects the community’s congratulations to Katrionna, and she will be waving to the crowd in Saturday’s May Festival Parade.
Enlarge Photo

She was a little girl with big dreams living in the small mountain town of Mammoth Lakes. Fifteen miles down the road, standing alone in the middle of the High Sierra desert, was Whitmore Outdoor Pool, so isolated that directions on their website state "turn left at the green church off U.S. 395". But it was where Katrionna Furness joined her first swim club, the Mammoth Sharks, at the age of 6 years, and where her love of swimming eventually brought her to First Place in the 100 Backstroke at the 2018 California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) Southern Section Division 4 finals, Riverside Aquatics Center, last Friday, May 14th.

"It was pretty cool," Kat, a junior at Fillmore High School (FHS), responded when asked about winning CIFs. "It made all the hard work worth it." It has been 13 years since a Fillmore High swimmer has qualified for CIF finals, and Kat is the first swimmer in Fillmore High's history to be a CIF Champion. She will be riding in Saturday’s May Festival Parade, under the Towne Theatre marquee which reads “Katrionna Furness CIF Champion”.

Kat swam seasonally in the popular resort town, three months a year, where the average snowfall is 200 to 500+ inches. But last August her dream brought her to Fillmore to swim year-round with the Buenaventura Swim Club, at the Ventura Aquatic Center on Kimball Road. She entered the club's Gold group in September and advanced to Senior group in December, under the direction of Senior Coach Jason York.

"Coach York inspired me to push myself and improve my technique. He changed my swimming."

Coach York told the Gazette, “I am very excited for Kat and her future. In just a short time with our team she has dropped a lot of time in a variety of events. She still has all summer and, of course, her senior year to improve even more. I anticipate her to gain valuable experience over the next season and expect her to be even better this time next year.”

The decision to leave her home and family for year-round training was not an easy one for the then-15 year old, or her parents Daniel and Chrissy Furness. Kat left Mammoth High School at the beginning of her junior year. She also left friends she has known since kindergarten, and her brother Ryan and sister Summer, both also competitive swimmers. But the drive she felt to pursue training and opportunity was strong, and she moved in with her grandparents, Fillmore residents Bert and Wanda Castel de Oro, to train year-round.

Kat is aware of the family support that has brought her to this victory. "I'm so thankful that my mom got me into this sport. My mom and dad have supported me in so many ways and made me want to do my best. They have made a lot of sacrifices so that I can be here now."

She joined Fillmore High School's swim team in January, training under coaches Mike and Cindy Blatt. Working with the Blatts and York, Kat dropped 10 seconds from her backstroke, ending with her winning CIF time of 59.68, nearly a second ahead of second-place Catherine Tran of La Quina, who touched in 1:00.66. Kat also took 3rd Place in the CIF 100 Freestyle, with a time of 54.21, 4.5 seconds off since training in Ventura County, and .56 behind second place winner Destiny Lewis of Grand Terrace. When asked about her local training Kat said, "Mike and Cindy [Blatt] always wanted me to do my best and taught me a lot about the groundwork of swimming.” She added with a laugh, “They taught me how to grab the touch pad."

“Kat scored 40 points, placing FHS 21st out of 47 teams scoring points at the Division 4 Championship,” said Cindy. “Coach Mike and I are very proud of Kat. She loves to race and proved to be a fierce competitor. She has inspired her teammates and we look forward to next year."

FHS Principal Tom Ito made the 3-hour drive from Fillmore to the CIF finals and cheered Kat on from the sidelines.
“As a former coach, I can say that athletes such as Katrionna are an exception. She has the focus and determination to achieve in the most trying of situations. She left her family and community with the intent to swim competitively for Fillmore High School. All year she has swam double workouts on a daily basis. At the CIF Finals she had just completed warming up and was ready to swim when the meet was stopped for a ten minute break. After the break, when she and the other athletes were ready to swim, the timing system went down. After a seven minute delay, the race finally started. Through each delay, where other athletes would have lost composure, Katrionna remained calm and focused and had a peak performance when it counted the most,” stated Ito.

Kat qualified for the Junior Olympics at the age of nine, and competed in July 2011 near San Francisco, where she made finals in her 50 Backstroke, the only Mammoth Shark ever to do so. She acquired a time standard beyond Junior Olympic and Far Western Time, placing 8th, despite her limited technique and lack of backstroke flip turn--but she had a champion's heart. She continued to qualify each year for Junior Olympics and consistently took Overall First Place at meets, swimming against year-round swimmers. She competed and qualified for finals at High Country League Championships in Minden, Nevada, King of the Hill meets held in Carson City, and consistently took first place at Swimming at Altitude at Lake Tahoe, where coaches from year-round swim teams would comment about her natural ability in the water, and encourage her to pursue full-time training.

Since moving to Southern California Kat has qualified for Winter Age Group (WAGs) which were held in December 2017 in Huntington Beach. She placed 12th in the prelims with her 50 Freestyle and made it to finals where she finished in 8th Place with a time of 25.84. She also qualified for finals in five events at the Canyon Qualifying Meet in Santa Clarita at the beginning of the year.

Her times since moving to Fillmore have steadily improved: 50 Free-dropping 2.6 seconds ending with a 25:84; 100 Free-4.5 seconds ending with a 55:21 at CIF; 200 Free-6 seconds ending with a 2:05; 500 Free-21 seconds ending with a 5:51.20; 100 Back-10 seconds ending with a 59:68; and 200 Back-10 seconds ending with a 2:19.49.

Kat will be participating in the June Age Group (JAGs) Invitational Swim Meet, June 14-17, hosted by the Buenaventura Swim Club. A GoFundMe account has been set up to help the Champ continue her training dreams https://www.gofundme.com/100-back-d4-champ-needs-help.

The Fillmore Gazette expects to see her at next year’s CIFs! Go Kat!!

 


 
Left to right, FUSD Superintendent Dr. Adrian Palazuelo, Baby Otter, Cindy Blatt, and Martha Richardson, introduce Fillmore Rotary Club’s effort to teach small children how to float, and swim. With a book about a baby otter learning how to float, the program alerts parents to the dangers of drowning when pools are unattended.
Left to right, FUSD Superintendent Dr. Adrian Palazuelo, Baby Otter, Cindy Blatt, and Martha Richardson, introduce Fillmore Rotary Club’s effort to teach small children how to float, and swim. With a book about a baby otter learning how to float, the program alerts parents to the dangers of drowning when pools are unattended.
Enlarge Photo
Fillmore Unified School District
Fillmore Unified School District

Mathematics Assessment Analysis and Overview
Information was presented to the Governing Board by Assistant Superintendent, Micheline G. Miglis.

Fillmore Unified Preschool Program Self-Evaluation
Information was presented to the Governing Board by Assistant Superintendent, Micheline G. Miglis and Child Development Director, Holly Harvan.

Approve Resolution No. 17-18-17 of the Fillmore Unified School District Ordering a Regular Governing Board Member Election, Ordering Consolidation with Other Elections, and Constituting “Specification of the Election Order” to be Held on November 6, 2018
The Governing Board approved Resolution No. 17-18-17.

Personnel Recommendations
The Governing Board approved all personnel recommendations including new hires, promotions, resignations, retirements, and leaves.

 


 
On Wednesday, 9th the Fillmore Public Safety Academy held a Graduation Ceremony for those who participated in the 12 week course, which allowed citizens to learn the function and operational procedures of the Police Department.
On Wednesday, 9th the Fillmore Public Safety Academy held a Graduation Ceremony for those who participated in the 12 week course, which allowed citizens to learn the function and operational procedures of the Police Department.
Enlarge Photo

The Fillmore Public Safety Academy provided community members with an inside look at local law enforcement. The 12-week course was designed to give citizens an overview of the police department’s function and operational procedures. Students met with members of the Police Department, Sheriff’s office, Fillmore Fire Department, Ventura County Superior Court, District Attorney’s office, and Probation Department, and discuss relevant issues affecting the community. They met once a week for approximately three hours at the Fillmore Active Adult Center. The curriculum and teaching methods were similar to the traditional Police Academy. However they were NOT designed to train the participants as police officers. The classes were taught by police officials and veteran police officers. Those who participated had the opportunity to meet with the Chief of Police and staff members. Each week was a different focus where students could ask questions, and express ideas or concerns.

 
Part 1 - “The seed is planted”

In the summer of 1952, Fillmore High School teacher and legendary Coach Richard “Toolie” Palmer was on his annual family vacation in Placerville, California when some of his local acquaintances from past summers, knowing he was a high school coach, asked Toolie if he would be interested in managing one of their newly formed Little League Baseball teams. Interested in new challenges and helping young people Toolie agreed. I’m not sure how successful his team was that summer, but for the future youth of Fillmore, it was a “Grand Slam Home Run”. That summer Toolie experienced a firsthand view of the benefits of what the young men of Placerville gained from their Little League experience.

Little League baseball began in Pennsylvania back in 1939 by Carl Stotz. The first game was played June 6th, 1939, in Williamsport, Pa, home of today’s Little League World Series. The first year consisted of three teams in one league. By 1946 there were 12 leagues in Pennsylvania, and by 1948 there were 94 leagues spread around the eastern United States. In 1951 the first teams outside of the United States formed in Canada and the Dominican Republic.

When Fillmore was granted their franchise, Ventura County’s only other league was in Ventura. They had two leagues, the America and the National Leagues. These leagues were some of the very first in California and were formed in 1950 or 51. Ventura’s third league, the Coastal League, received their Little League franchise in 1954, the same year as Fillmore. There were 3,300 leagues all over the World by 1954. Under the Little League organization’s umbrella in 2008, there are 12 different types of leagues (Jr., Sr., hard ball, softball, boys and girls) with leagues in all 50 states and 80 countries, with 2.6 million players on 200,000 teams. During the last 80 years, more than 40 million kids, both boys and girls from around the world, have played Little League baseball.

Back in Fillmore that following fall, Toolie enthusiastically shared his experience of the summer with like minded youth oriented friends, and thus the seed was planted. This small group of friends started to form the organization. They enlisted others and obtained information on the rules and regulations of Little League and how to start the franchise application process.

“Securing a Sponsor”
On Monday, July 6th 1953 Toolie and the newly formed committee approached the Lions Club of Fillmore. They presented their plan for organizing a “Little League Baseball Club” for the young men of Fillmore, Piru, and Bardsdale. The members of the Lion’s Club unanimously approved the plan and graciously consented to underwrite all costs. Now all that was left to do was to create an organization, requite additional personnel and create a plan with a timeline. The last thing to do was to secure players, organize teams and then play ball. Because it had been Fillmore’s first year and it was already late in the summer when they decided to just expose the boys to hardball with some fundamental training, then play a limited schedule.

The members of the original organizing committee in addition to Toolie Palmer were; Chuck Mulvihill, an ex-major league baseball player who played in a couple of World Series; Hank “The Oklahoma Flash” Data, an avid local youth supporter. Ken Creed, a Fillmore High School teacher and coach; Bob Hustis, a local postman who was an outstanding athlete, as was Toolie, at Fillmore High School. Eventually others became Board Members before the first full season, but these four were the original organizers.

...Part 2 of the story to be continued next.

 
On Tuesday, May 15th 100 students from Mountain Vista Elementary School had a special visitor, Fillmore’s very own Kathy Meza who takes the time once a year to stop by every Fillmore Elementary school to read and teaches them about supermarkets. She explains the in’s and out’s of the supermarket world, from what kind of bags the markets use to even bringing a toy shopping cart filled with fruits and veggies to show the kids. At the end of her presentations she fields questions from the kids and finally rewards them with cookies for all the listeners.
On Tuesday, May 15th 100 students from Mountain Vista Elementary School had a special visitor, Fillmore’s very own Kathy Meza who takes the time once a year to stop by every Fillmore Elementary school to read and teaches them about supermarkets. She explains the in’s and out’s of the supermarket world, from what kind of bags the markets use to even bringing a toy shopping cart filled with fruits and veggies to show the kids. At the end of her presentations she fields questions from the kids and finally rewards them with cookies for all the listeners.
Enlarge Photo
 
Photo of the Week "Steam engine train rounding curve" by Bob Crum. Photo data: Canon 7DMKII camera, ISO 200, Tamron 16-300mm lens @18mm, aperture f/7.1, 1/320 second shutter speed.
Photo of the Week "Steam engine train rounding curve" by Bob Crum. Photo data: Canon 7DMKII camera, ISO 200, Tamron 16-300mm lens @18mm, aperture f/7.1, 1/320 second shutter speed.
Enlarge Photo
Point-and-Shoots
Bob Crum
Bob Crum
All photos by Bob Crum.
All photos by Bob Crum.
Enlarge Photo

Though I often contemplate unmercifully admonishing Buy A Camera! my saintly conscience dictates entice gently. Thus you are spared undue wrath which I suspect would ultimately serve no useful purpose anyway.

A constant email question: Why do I need a camera while my smartphone takes fine photos? Smartphones are wonderful for “snaptography... not photography! Let's explore & discover”. Beware: The intent is to convert you!

Yes, a few ubiquitous smartphones sport some useful features; optical image stabilization, better autofocus systems and shutter speed adjustments. The cliché the best camera is the one you have with you obviously applies to smartphones... presuming that you don't own a “real” camera.

However, a smartphone is a generalist device. As a camera, a cursory glance of smartphone camera specs quickly reveal several deficiencies. That hurts, I know. Phonetographers want their smartphone to also be a 'great' camera. It ain't! If you want superior image quality, and photography experience, a dedicated camera is paramount.

The compactness of smartphones prevents optical zooms which is superior. Hence, they employ inferior digital zooming. A digital zoomed image is merely cropped and expanded, decreasing resolution and image quality to varying degrees.

Smartphones also suffer from incredibly small sensors. A tiny sensor decreases dynamic range which affects how many colors the sensor can accurately produce. Larger sensors of dedicated cameras mean higher dynamic range and decreased noise levels in dim light resulting in much better image quality.

Depth of field is important in the photographic creative process. Most smartphones utilize wide-angle lenses. Great for bokeh... not depth of field. So what? Depth of field matters greatly if you intend to creatively control image composition.

Dedicated camera battery life is much greater. A smartphone's ultra compact size prevents using robust batteries, just enough power to get through a day of normal use. Shoot some smartphone photos/video and the battery energy is quickly depleted. Note that camera batteries are swappable in the field if needed. Nice.

For ultimate convenience, can't beat smartphones. But for quality photos, a dedicated camera kicks smartphones to the curb. Image quality, accompanied with enhanced creativity, dedicated digital cameras will continue to be a great purchase far into the future. By the way, anyone see an 8 X 10 print from a cropped smartphone photo? It's awful!

The June issue of Consumer Reports includes an interesting camera article. CR contends that most consumers trading up from a phone camera will be pleased with the a class of cameras called 'enhanced' point-and-shoots. Also referred to as 'bridge' cameras, they utilize fixed lenses which are quite sharp as indicated in camera reviews.

Enhanced point-and-shoot cameras also provide for manual control. They also capture photos in the RAW file format, important for non-destructive photo editing.

A small sample of CR's rated point-and-shoots: Canon PowerShot G7 X Mark II, Canon PowerShot G3 X, Sony Cyber-shot RX10, Sony Cyber-shot RX100IV, Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX100, Panasonic LX10. For the adventurous, there isn’t a better rugged waterproof compact around than the Olympus TOUGH TG-5. Here's a link to a valuable camera review resource to help you with due diligence... https://www.the-digital-picture.com/Reviews/ Next: dSLR cameras.

The photo of the week is another of the magnificent steam engine shot during the recent Railfest. The composition is one of many creative options. Point being, most situations will offer multiple options for framing the composition. A camera and an artistic eye create memorable photographs. Exercising creativity makes photography profoundly gratifying. Not only is photography an exceptionally rewarding experience, it is also an unconditional means of expression. Cameras provide the means!!! Convinced?

Send comments, suggestions, questions to bob@fillmoregazette.com

 
At last night’s meeting Council announced the Fourth of July Fireworks show along with other city business.
At last night’s meeting Council announced the Fourth of July Fireworks show along with other city business.
Enlarge Photo

At last night’s meeting the council announced the Fourth of July Fireworks show along with other city business.
City Council approved for sale the vacant property located at 510 Santa Clara Street, to Aman Gupta, Rakhee Gupta, and Amary Grewal as purchasers. The property is being sold in compliance with state regulations and in accordance with the City’s State-approved Long-Range Property Management Plan.

City Council unanimously approved Zoning Ordinance Amendment 18-01, amending the City of Fillmore Zoning Ordinance to allow for the creation of new original art murals and finding of CEQA Exemption.

Council approved the recommendation that they implement Measure I to update the North Fillmore Specific Plan: Rincon, Jensen design, and RRM for a total not to exceed $83,016.

The recommendation to approve Memorandum of agreement between Fillmore Unified School District and City of Fillmore for School Resource Officer, on a 50-50 basis, was approved unanimously.

City Council Resolution No. 18-3649 Calling and Giving Notice of the November 6, 2018, General Municipal Election and Resolution No. 18-3650, Requesting Consolidation with the Gubernatorial General Election being conducted by the County of Ventura the same day, was unanimously approved.

Mayor Manuel Minjares was appointed Primary to Joint Powers Insurance Authority Board of Directors.

The Planning Commission has one seat which was recently discovered expired on January 31, 2017. Christopher Hoy held the Commissioner seat that expired and is the only applicant after a two week recruitment. Mr. Hoy was reappointed to the Planning Commission.

City Council considered and approved the Ventra County Animal Services contract.

The 2018 July Fourth Community Fireworks Show was authorized, and the contract with Exposhows, Inc. in the amount of $15,000 as well. The show will take place at the Fillmore Middle School field. The cost of the 2018 show is mostly covered by contributions from the suppliers (Fillmore & Western Railways, TNT Fireworks and Phantom Fireworks) and by fireworks booth permit fees.

 
Jose Luis Luna, 56, Santa Paula.
Jose Luis Luna, 56, Santa Paula.

A Santa Paula resident was arrested Wednesday for the theft of a vehicle in the city of Fillmore on April 4, 2018. The victim, who is a Fillmore resident, reported that his vehicle had been stolen from the parking lot of a grocery store in Fillmore while he had been inside shopping. On April 6, 2018, the victim was in the city of Santa Paula and found his stolen vehicle parked in a condominium complex, where two men appeared to be working on the vehicle. The two men fled the area when the victim approached them.

The investigation revealed Jose Luna was one of the two suspects who had fled the area and was responsible for the theft of the vehicle. On May 2, 2018, Fillmore detectives located Luna near the 400-block of Harvard Boulevard in Santa Paula and arrested him for vehicle theft. Luna was booked at the Pre-Trail Detention Facility for vehicle theft, possession of a controlled substance and possession of drug paraphernalia. Luna is currently in custody awaiting arraignment with a bail of $75,000.

The Ventura County Sheriff’s Office wants to remind citizens to keep vehicles locked and to not leave the keys inside their unattended automobiles. Residents are encouraged to report suspicious activity, such as people looking into cars and/or loitering where vehicles are parked.

Prepared by: Detective Bill Meixner #3695, Approved by: Captain Eric Tennessen.

 
Part of the live simulation is the driver being arrested by officers for driving under the influence.
Part of the live simulation is the driver being arrested by officers for driving under the influence.
Enlarge Photo

City of Fillmore Fire Department and the Ventura County Sheriffs Department presented a nationally recognized program to stop underage alcohol consumption and driving. The program entitled “Every 15 Minutes” which is a two-day program that involves juniors and seniors at Fillmore High School. The program agenda was as follows:

Part I: “Living Dead” - students were removed from class during the first four hours of the day and made up with white faces and black shirts to represent them as an alcohol related death over the proceeding 48 hours. The students were not allowed to speak with any other students, staff or family for the rest of the school day. The students were then lead to part II of the presentation and standby throughout the event.

Part II: Mock Vehicle Crash. On May 4th at 10:30am all juniors and seniors were escorted to intersection of Shiells Drive & Second Street, where the students were able to see a real time simulation of a motor vehicle accident resulting from alcohol
consumption.

 
Back Row: Attorney Coach Gary Jacobs, freshman George Mooradian, junior Edgar Gonzalez, junior Damian Meza, sophomore Lilly Diaz, senior Alexander Ponce, freshman Olivia Palazuelos, junior Fatima Bazurto, freshman Melissa Tovar, freshman Montana Spangler, sophomore Isabella Palazuelos, senior Paulina Guerrero, senior Maria Elena Fernandez, coach Jacqueline Tovar, Captain senior Mishell Beylik, attorney coach Laura Bartels. Front row: senior Manuel Gutierrez, freshman Jorge Lizárraga, junior Jerry Tovar, senior Alina Herrera, Faculty /Attorney Coach Steven Geddes.
Back Row: Attorney Coach Gary Jacobs, freshman George Mooradian, junior Edgar Gonzalez, junior Damian Meza, sophomore Lilly Diaz, senior Alexander Ponce, freshman Olivia Palazuelos, junior Fatima Bazurto, freshman Melissa Tovar, freshman Montana Spangler, sophomore Isabella Palazuelos, senior Paulina Guerrero, senior Maria Elena Fernandez, coach Jacqueline Tovar, Captain senior Mishell Beylik, attorney coach Laura Bartels. Front row: senior Manuel Gutierrez, freshman Jorge Lizárraga, junior Jerry Tovar, senior Alina Herrera, Faculty /Attorney Coach Steven Geddes.
Enlarge Photo

Written By Laura Bartels and Steven Geddes

Fillmore High’s legal team made major strides during the Ventura County Mock Trial competition on February 26th and 27th, 2018. The highlight of the competition was Fillmore’s defense team saving their defendant from a life sentence with a NOT GUILTY verdict against both Villanova and Pacifica High Schools. The Fillmore team, now in its sixth year, consisted of 6 seniors, 4 juniors, 2 sophomores and 5 freshmen. At the awards ceremony held at the Oxnard Civic Arts Center, freshman Olivia Palazuelos won a Ventura County Second Place Award as defense witness Acorn Shop Owner Avery Williams; senior Paulina Guerrero won Third Place as Prosecution witness Morgan Bonderman; and senior Mishell Beylik received a Most Valuable Player award was also garnering admiration from her team and coaches for her leadership. Mishell Beylik was also recognized and honored along with Manuel Gutierrez and Paulina Guerrero for participating in mock trial all four years of high school.

This year’s fictitious case, People v. Davidson, was the trial of Casey Davidson, a young person advocating liberal immigration policies who faced a felony homicide charge of the murder of foe Alex Thompson, an advocate from a conservative group seeking to limit immigration. Davidson’s defense team kept her out of prison with showing the court that the prosecution could not prove its case “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Fillmore High School students portrayed each principal of the cast in a courtroom, including attorneys, witnesses, defendant, court clerk, and bailiff. The trial was performed in real courtrooms at the Ventura Superior Court before actual judges and scored by Ventura County practicing attorneys.

The trials all begin a pre-trial motion designed to exclude evidence gained by what defense claims is an illegal search. This year’s pre-trial motion focused on the Fourth Amendment protection against the government using GPS location data from a third party GPS provider to track the defendant. In the case, the police detective obtained a court order pursuant to the Stored Communications Act to obtain location data for the defendant’s car late at night over the course of a couple of weeks at victim’s warehouse. The GPS data from Defendant’s car communicated the location to satellites in space and with this information, the location of the car GPS can be tracked within 50 feet of its precise location. GPS and satellite companies keep and retain location data to help them improve features of their products. Freshman George Mooradian won both his motions arguing that the government is allowed to track people using GPS technology. The present laws which were written before the widespread use of cell phone location data and electronic tracking allows such invasions of privacy. The defense junior Edgar Gonzalez argued that the antiquated Stored Communications Act provides too wide a loophole for law enforcement to routinely track people. The students were able to follow the actual case which the fictitious case was based when they heard oral arguments before the United States Supreme Court in November 2017 in People v. Carpenter. It is anticipated that the results of the Supreme Court case will have landmark implications for the 4th amendment and privacy laws.

The prosecution attorneys, senior Mishell Beylik, junior Damian Mesa, and sophomore Isabella Palazuelos hit the ground running in round one against Rio Mesa High School and again in round three against Agoura High School. Prosecution attorney for pre-trial motion, freshman George Mooradian, strongly presented the prosecution’s argument of the law which the court was required to follow due to precedent which allowed tracking a person using a car GPS. The judge was so compelled by Attorney Mooradian’s persuasive nature, keen understanding of the facts and understanding of the nuances of the law that he denied the defense’s motion This win gave Fillmore’s prosecution a huge advantage resulting in a guilty verdict and one of Fillmore’s highest scoring rounds as well as a nomination nod to Mr. Mooradian for Best Pretrial Attorney.

In a strong opening statement, senior Mishell Beylik articulated the prosecution’s theory of motive, means and opportunity and tied the facts of the case to each element of the law of first degree murder. She developed for the judge and jury, how the prosecution would prove ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’ that the defendant was guilty. Attorney Beylik’s convincing performance was singled out for comment by one of the scoring attorneys and she admirably scored solid blocks of 8s and 9. Prosecution attorney junior Damian Mesa garnered a perfect 10 for his prosecutorial skills and strong control of the courtroom. Sophomore and new to the team Isabella Palazuelos scored solid 8s and 9s. Ms. Palanzuelos was recognized and praised by the scoring attorneys for her bright and calculated cross examination of opposing team witnesses.

The police detective witness was played convincingly by senior Maria Elena Fernandez earning 8s and 9s. Freshman Montana Spangler played the expert medical examiner Devon Morrison who had to have a keen and facile understanding of wounds due to blunt force trauma, blood splatter and skin cell DNA. Ms. Spangler’s spunk, humor and tenacity earned her strong scores, including a 9 which is a huge accomplishment for a first year participant in mock trial. Freshman Melissa Tovar played the role of the local newspaper reporter Hayden Rodriguez earning an admirable score of 8. Ms. Tovar was extremely important to the team as she was able to fill in when there were unexpected vacancies. Senior Paulina Guerrero played Morgan Bonderman, friend of the victim bringing believability and credibility to the character and earning the 3rd place witness award at the county level as well as strong team scores. Rounding out the prosecution was new to the team senior Alexander Ponce whose job as Court Clerk was to keep the official time, a crucial role in a competition in which every second counts. Clerk Ponce accurately handled the timing for both the Fillmore and the challenging teams. His performance not only received a score of a perfect “10” by scoring attorneys, but also was nominated as “Best Clerk” at the Oxnard Civic Arts Center.

Fillmore’s strong defense attorneys senior Manuel Gutierrez and juniors Jerry Tovar and Fatima Bazurto took control of the courtroom to spare the life of their defendant in round two against Villanova High School, and in round three against Pacifica High School. The Defense Team opened with a pre-trial motion to suppress the police’s tracking the defendant via the car’s GPS tracking system. Citing United States Supreme Court case law, senior Edgar Gonzalez argued that the defendant’s right to privacy are violated under the protections of the Fourth Amendment and that government tracking people privately is exactly what the fourth amendment should be protecting. Superior Court Judge Mindy Johnson (ret.) agreed with Mr. Gonzalez and believed that this kind of police tracking it too intrusive as held against the 4th amendment privacy protections. By winning the pre-trial motion, Mr. Gonzalez was able to set the stage for the defense to have the evidence of the police misconduct suppressed which contributed greatly to a not guilty verdict.

With a thoughtful and pragmatic opening statement, Manual Gutierrez set the scene of how there was inadequate evidence to convict the defendant. Mr. Gutierrez walked the jury through how it was not possible for the jury to be able to get over the prosecutorial burden of beyond a reasonable doubt and he garnered laughs when he invoked the game of Clue debating whether it was “Mrs. Peacock in the Observatory with the Candlestick.” Junior Fatima Bazurto received a nomination for her role as defense attorney. Now in her third year of mock trial, Ms. Bazurto is quick to think on her feet and her intelligent cross examinations of witnesses earned her high scores. Closer junior Jerry Tovar brought in solid scores and circled the wagons around the game of Clue referencing the old popular board game. He also cleverly reminded the scorers of the burden of proof and if there were reasonable interpretations of guilt and of innocence that the trier of fact must accept the interpretations that points to innocence. The jury was convinced and not guilty verdicts were received in both trials.

Senior Paulina Guerrero portrayed defense expert witness Dr. Tory Lee effectively eliminating any plausible explanation proffered by prosecution of the murder weapon. She earned a coveted score of “10.” Newcomer to the team and freshman Oliva Palazuelos won second place at the County for her role as the Tech Shop Owner. And strong scores from the scoring attorneys. Freshman Jorge Lizarraga played defense witness Fabian Moreno, a history teacher with a mysterious past. He earned a 9 for his strong, solid and believable performance. Newcomer senior Alina Herrera played the Defendant who was relieved for her 2 not guilty verdicts from her strong defense team. Collected and confident, Defendant Herrera received a nomination as “Best Defendant.” Sophomore Lilly Diaz as Bailiff scored 9s and a perfect 10 for her control of the courtroom and protecting the judge. Bailiff Diaz with a kind but firm manner made sure the trial was free from cell phones, talking and eating.

At the awards ceremony at the Oxnard Civic Center, the Fillmore team received two impressive “Best of” awards; 10 “best of” nominations; and over the two nights of competition earned four perfect “10” scores. The Prosecution team received one guilty verdict and the Defense team received two not guilty verdicts. The team ended the competition solidly. The students owe their success to long hours of research, preparation and practice, including lunch time, vacations, after school, and weekends.

At the team awards banquet the following awards were created, voted and given by the students: Best Attorney and Most Likely to Moderately Succeed: Mishell Beylik; Best Witness- Paulina Guerrero; Most Likely to be an Attorney: Isabella Palazuelos; Most Likely to End Up In Jail and Most Likely to Be Charged with Felony- Damian Meza; Most Spirited- Manuel Gutierrez; Most Likely to Get Away with Murder- George Mooradian.

The coaching staff consisted of school advisor, teacher and attorney Steven Geddes, attorney coach Laura Bartels of Taylor, Scoles and Bartels in Fillmore, attorney coach Gary Jacobs of Ventura; special coaches Jacqueline Tovar and Misael Ponce. Parents and teachers provided the students with invaluable advice and support, including law office staff Andrea Davis; Joi Searson and Grace Kline. Special thanks to La Fondita for helping with burritos; team parents: Mr. and Mrs. Mesa, Mr. and Mrs. Tovar, Szilvia Beylik; Principal Ito, Barbara Lemons, Fillmore Rotary Club, and patrons Val and Craig Sather.